Boss Ordered to Pay Up After Unfair Sacking for Questioning Overtime
An employment tribunal has ruled in favour of a worker unfairly dismissed after questioning overtime payments, awarding them substantial compensation.
• public
Overtime Query Leads to Unfair Dismissal
An employee's simple question about overtime has resulted in a costly lesson for their former employer. An employment tribunal has found that the worker was unfairly dismissed after raising concerns about the accuracy of their overtime payments. The tribunal's decision highlights the importance of employers addressing employee concerns fairly and transparently.
The Case Details
The employee questioned their overtime calculations. Instead of addressing the concerns, the employer took disciplinary action, ultimately leading to the employee's dismissal. The tribunal scrutinised the employer's actions and found them to be unreasonable, concluding that the dismissal was indeed unfair.
Tribunal Findings
The tribunal's judgment criticised the employer's handling of the situation. Key factors in the tribunal's decision included the lack of a fair process, the severity of the disciplinary action in response to a simple query, and a general lack of evidence to support the employer's claims. The tribunal noted that a reasonable employer would have investigated the overtime concerns and attempted to resolve the issue amicably.
Compensation Awarded
As a result of the unfair dismissal finding, the employee was awarded compensation. The amount of compensation has not been explicitly released but it covers lost earnings, future losses, and injury to feelings. This case serves as a reminder to employers that they must act fairly and reasonably when dealing with employee concerns.
Lessons for Employers
This case provides valuable lessons for employers across the UK. It underscores the importance of:
- Having clear and transparent overtime policies.
- Addressing employee concerns promptly and fairly.
- Following a fair and reasonable disciplinary process.
- Seeking professional advice when dealing with complex employment issues.
Ignoring these principles can lead to costly employment tribunal claims and reputational damage. It's always better to handle employee issues with care and attention to detail.
This case also serves as a reminder to employees to seek legal advice if they believe they have been unfairly dismissed. Employees have rights, and this case demonstrates that tribunals are willing to uphold those rights.
It is important to note that every case is unique, and the outcome of an employment tribunal will depend on the specific facts and circumstances.
Read the entire judgement here: Dr Graeme Madden v Waracle Limited and Paystream My Max Limited [2025] EAT 173
